Advertisement
You've probably seen them everywhere — those tall, green, column-like shrubs lining fences and hiding neighbors' backyards. Arborvitae trees have become the go-to choice for privacy screens across America, and for good reason. But here's the thing: they're not perfect. In fact, I've talked to plenty of homeowners who planted a row of these evergreens, only to deal with browning, splitting, or deer damage a few years later. So before you make a decision, let me walk you through the real arborvitae pros and cons — the honest advantages and the downsides you don't hear about at the nursery.I've spent years working with landscapes and talking to gardeners who've tried everything. Some people swear by arborvitae, while others wish they'd never planted them. The truth lies somewhere in the middle. These evergreen shrubs (Thuja spp.) belong to the cypress family and grow in USDA zones 3 through 11, depending on the variety. They're fast-growing, easy to find, and relatively cheap. But they also come with a list of drawbacks that can turn your dream hedge into a headache. In this article, I'll break down the arborvitae disadvantages and benefits so you can decide for yourself — no fluff, just real talk.
E.g. ：10 Common Vegetable Gardening Mistakes (and How to Fix Them)
You've probably seen them everywhere — those tall, green, column-like shrubs lining fences and hiding neighbors' backyards. Arborvitae trees have become the go-to choice for privacy screens across America, and for good reason. But here's the thing: they're not perfect. In fact, I've talked to plenty of homeowners who planted a row of these evergreens, only to deal with browning, splitting, or deer damage a few years later. So before you make a decision, let me walk you through the real arborvitae pros and cons — the honest advantages and the downsides you don't hear about at the nursery.
I've spent years working with landscapes and talking to gardeners who've tried everything. Some people swear by arborvitae, while others wish they'd never planted them. The truth lies somewhere in the middle. These evergreen shrubs (Thuja spp.) belong to the cypress family and grow in USDA zones 3 through 11, depending on the variety. They're fast-growing, easy to find, and relatively cheap. But they also come with a list of drawbacks that can turn your dream hedge into a headache. In this article, I'll break down the arborvitae disadvantages and benefits so you can decide for yourself — no fluff, just real talk.
Let's be honest — the main reason most people plant arborvitae is speed. You want a privacy screen, and you want it yesterday. Arborvitae delivers. Some varieties put on a full 3 feet of growth each year, hitting 15 to 20 feet tall in no time. That's hard to beat when you're trying to block out a nosy neighbor or a busy road. And because they're evergreen, that screen stays green and full all winter long. No bare branches, no gaps — just solid coverage.
I remember a client who planted a row of 'Green Giant' arborvitae along her property line. Within three years, she had a 12-foot wall of green that completely transformed her backyard. You just don't get that kind of speed with most other evergreens. But here's the catch — fast growth means you need to plan ahead. These trees spread out as they grow, so spacing them too close leads to crowding and disease down the road. I always recommend checking the mature width of your specific variety before planting. And if you're in a hurry, remember that arborvitae benefits include instant gratification, but only if you give them room to breathe. That quick growth also means you'll need to stay on top of pruning, especially if you want a neat, manicured look. Otherwise, they'll do their own thing — which might be fine if you're going for a natural style.
Here's what I love about arborvitae: once they're established, you barely have to touch them. No fertilizing, no regular pruning, no fussing over complicated soil conditions. They grow in most soil types as long as the drainage is decent. They're moderately drought-tolerant too, which means you don't have to run the sprinkler every time the sun comes out. That's a huge win for lazy gardeners like me.
But let me clarify what "low maintenance" really means in practice. You still need to water them deeply during their first year or two — that's non-negotiable. After that, they can handle dry spells, but a long drought will stress them out and cause browning. I've seen perfectly healthy arborvitae rows turn brown and patchy after a hot, dry summer. The trees usually recover, but they look terrible in the meantime. Another thing to watch: they don't need fertilizer, but a light application of balanced slow-release fertilizer in spring can boost growth. And while they don't require pruning, you might want to trim them for shape or to control height. Just remember — never cut back to bare wood, because those branches won't grow back. Arborvitae pros and cons really come down to how much effort you're willing to put in during those first couple of years. If you can handle that, they're about as easy-going as an evergreen gets.
Photos provided by pixabay
You can pick up a small arborvitae for under $20 at most garden centers. Compare that to slower-growing evergreens, and you'll see why budget-conscious homeowners love them. They grow fast enough that you don't need to buy mature specimens — just wait a couple of seasons, and you've got a decent-sized hedge. Plus, those dense branches provide shelter for birds and small mammals all year long. In winter, when other plants are bare, arborvitae offer a safe haven for wildlife.
I've watched chickadees and finches nest in my own arborvitae hedge year after year. Some varieties also produce small cones with seeds that birds enjoy. That's a nice bonus if you're into backyard wildlife watching. But here's the thing — those same trees that attract birds can also attract deer. If you live in an area with a heavy deer population, you might see your hedge get nibbled down to sticks. I've had clients lose entire rows to deer browsing in winter when food is scarce. So while the affordability is a real plus, you need to factor in potential losses. When weighing arborvitae disadvantages and benefits, consider your local wildlife situation. If deer are a problem, you might need to protect your trees with netting or choose a less tasty alternative. The good news is that for most suburban areas, the wildlife benefits outweigh the risks — just keep an eye out.
I hate to break it to you, but arborvitae are drama queens. Give them less-than-perfect conditions, and they'll let you know by turning brown. Drought, dry winter winds, road salt, even too much shade — they all cause needle drop and browning. And once the needles brown, they don't always come back. That's a problem when you're counting on a solid green hedge. I've seen beautiful rows of arborvitae get ruined by a single harsh winter or a construction project that changed the drainage.
Let me give you a real example. A friend of mine planted a hedge along his driveway, right where the snow plow piles up salty slush. Within two years, the bottom half of every tree was brown and dead. The salt damage was irreversible. He ended up replacing the whole row with a salt-tolerant juniper variety. This is one of the biggest arborvitae disadvantages — they're picky about location. They need full sun to partial shade, well-drained soil, and protection from harsh winds. If you plant them in a low spot where water collects, expect root rot. If you plant them in heavy clay, expect slow growth and yellowing. I'm not saying you can't make them work — but you need to choose your site carefully. Another thing to watch: winter burn. Evergreen foliage loses moisture through the leaves, and if the ground is frozen, the roots can't replace it. The result is brown, crispy foliage on the windward side. You can minimize this by watering deeply before the ground freezes and using an anti-desiccant spray, but it's not foolproof. When you look at arborvitae pros and cons, the sensitivity issue is a major con that many people overlook.
Here's a frustration I hear all the time: "My arborvitae split right down the middle." These trees love to grow double leaders — two main trunks that form a V shape. That V is a weak point. Heavy snow, ice, or a strong wind can split them apart, leaving an ugly gap in your hedge. I've seen entire rows of mature arborvitae destroyed by a single ice storm. And once they split, there's no easy fix. You can try to tie them together, but the damage is usually permanent.
Then there's the pest problem. Bagworms love arborvitae. These little caterpillars build protective bags out of foliage and silk, and they can defoliate an entire tree in a season. Because most people plant arborvitae close together in rows, bagworms spread from tree to tree like wildfire. I've had clients who didn't notice the infestation until half their hedge was brown. Arborvitae disadvantages and benefits include this serious pest risk. Deer are another issue — they'll browse on arborvitae during winter, especially when food is scarce. In areas with high deer populations, you might need to wrap your trees in burlap or use repellents. And don't forget about spider mites and scale insects, which can cause yellowing and needle drop. The bottom line: arborvitae aren't as pest-free as some people claim. They have fewer problems than many plants, but when they do get hit, the damage can be severe. If you're looking for a truly low-maintenance option, you might want to consider alternatives that are more resistant to pests and breakage.
Photos provided by pixabay
Let's talk about the elephant in the room — or rather, the row of identical green columns. Arborvitae are everywhere. Drive through any suburban neighborhood, and you'll see them lining fences, hiding AC units, and blocking views. They've become the default choice for privacy, and honestly, they're boring. I've walked down streets where every single house has the same 'Green Giant' hedge. It's like looking at a wall of green soldiers — functional, but not exactly inspiring.
I get it — you want privacy, and arborvitae deliver. But there's a whole world of evergreen options that offer more texture, color, and interest. Think about it: a row of arborvitae looks the same in January as it does in July. No flowers, no berries, no seasonal change. Compare that to a mixed hedge with hollies, junipers, and flowering shrubs. You get different heights, textures, and even winter berries for birds. I've started recommending that clients use arborvitae as part of a mixed planting rather than a solid row. When considering arborvitae pros and cons, ask yourself if you really want a monoculture in your yard. Besides the visual boredom, planting all the same species makes your landscape vulnerable. If a disease or pest targets arborvitae, your entire hedge could be wiped out. Diversity isn't just beautiful — it's smart. I'm not saying you should never plant arborvitae. Just don't make them the only thing in your yard. Mix it up, and your landscape will look better and last longer.
You can minimize most problems by planting the right way. First, space them properly. I know you want instant density, but crowding leads to disease and poor air circulation. Follow the mature width recommendations for your variety — usually 4 to 6 feet apart for most types. Second, choose a site with good drainage and full sun. Avoid low spots, road salt zones, and areas exposed to harsh winds. Third, water deeply during dry spells, especially in the first two years.
I've found that a little prevention goes a long way. If you live in a deer-heavy area, consider using deer repellent or installing fencing around your hedge. For bagworms, inspect your trees in late winter and remove any bags you see. A simple hand-picking session can prevent a full-blown infestation. The key to managing arborvitae disadvantages and benefits is understanding that these trees need a little TLC to thrive. Another tip: prune your arborvitae to encourage a single leader. If you spot a double leader early, you can remove one of them to reduce the risk of splitting later. Also, consider using a snow guard or tying branches loosely together in winter to prevent snow damage. I've done this for clients in heavy snowfall areas, and it makes a big difference. One more thing: don't plant arborvitae right next to your house or driveway. The reflected heat from walls and pavement can stress them out, and salt spray from roads is deadly. Give them at least 3 to 4 feet of clearance from hard surfaces. These small steps can turn a problem hedge into a thriving one.
Here's my best advice: don't plant a straight row of arborvitae. Instead, use them as part of a mixed-species hedge. Combine them with junipers, hollies, or even deciduous shrubs that provide seasonal interest. This approach reduces the risk of pest and disease outbreaks, and it looks way more interesting. I've designed mixed hedges for clients that include arborvitae for structure, with flowering shrubs for color and evergreens like yew for texture.
Let me give you a specific example. I worked with a client who wanted a privacy screen that wasn't "boring." We planted a row of 'Green Giant' arborvitae as the backbone, spaced about 8 feet apart. In between, we added 'Sky Pencil' holly for vertical accent, and 'Blue Star' juniper for low ground cover. The result was a layered, textured screen that changed with the seasons. It provided privacy year-round, but it also had visual interest that a pure arborvitae hedge would never have. When you look at arborvitae pros and cons, remember that the biggest con — monotony — is avoidable with a little creativity. Plus, a mixed hedge is more resilient. If bagworms or deer target the arborvitae, the other plants remain unaffected. I've seen mixed hedges survive pest outbreaks that would have devastated a monoculture. Another benefit: different root systems use different soil layers, which means less competition and healthier overall growth. If you're set on arborvitae, at least give them some companions. Your yard will thank you.
Photos provided by pixabay
If you're having second thoughts about arborvitae, consider junipers. Junipers come in upright varieties that rival arborvitae for height, but they're tougher. They handle drought, salt, and poor soil better than arborvitae. They also resist deer and most pests. I've planted 'Skyrocket' juniper in places where arborvitae would have died, and they thrive. Hollies are another great option. 'Nellie Stevens' holly grows fast, stays dense, and produces red berries that birds love. Plus, they're evergreen and deer-resistant.
Let me break down the differences in a way that helps you decide. I've put together a comparison table based on my experience and common nursery data. Remember, exact numbers vary by variety and region, but these ranges give you a reliable picture. This table covers the most popular alternatives to arborvitae for privacy screens.
| Species | Growth Rate | Mature Height | Deer Resistance | Pest Issues | Maintenance Level |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Arborvitae (Thuja) | Fast (2-3 ft/yr) | 15-20 ft | Low | Bagworms, spider mites | Low to moderate |
| Juniper (Juniperus) | Moderate (1-2 ft/yr) | 10-15 ft | High | Minimal | Low |
| Holly (Ilex) | Moderate (1-2 ft/yr) | 15-25 ft | High | Scale, leaf miners | Low to moderate |
| Cypress (Cupressus) | Fast (2-3 ft/yr) | 20-30 ft | Moderate | Minimal | Low |
As you can see, junipers and hollies offer better deer resistance and fewer pest problems. Cypress trees grow just as fast as arborvitae but with stronger wood and better drought tolerance. I've used 'Carolina Sapphire' cypress in several projects, and it's been a reliable performer. When weighing arborvitae disadvantages and benefits, these alternatives can tip the scale. The only downside? Some of these options cost a bit more upfront or grow slower initially. But if you factor in the reduced risk of damage and replacement costs, they often come out ahead.
You might not have considered cypress as an arborvitae alternative. Leyland cypress and Italian cypress are both excellent choices for tall, fast-growing screens. Leyland cypress can grow 3 to 4 feet per year and reach 50 feet tall, making it one of the fastest options out there. It's also more resistant to bagworms and deer than arborvitae. Italian cypress has a narrower, columnar shape that works well for tight spaces. Another option: yew (Taxus). Yews are shade-tolerant, deer-resistant, and respond well to pruning. They don't grow as fast, but they're incredibly reliable.
I want to address a common question I get: "Should I plant arborvitae or cypress for privacy?" It depends on your priorities. If you need a screen quickly and don't mind some maintenance, arborvitae works. But if you want something that will last longer with fewer problems, cypress or juniper is a better bet. I've seen 20-year-old cypress hedges that still look perfect, while arborvitae hedges of the same age have gaps and brown spots. When you consider the long-term arborvitae disadvantages and benefits, the alternatives start to look really attractive. Another option I like is 'Emerald' arborvitae — it's a smaller, denser variety that's less prone to splitting than 'Green Giant'. But it still has the same deer and pest issues. If you're in a zone 7 or warmer, consider 'Green Beauty' boxwood or 'Dwarf' yaupon holly. These stay smaller but offer evergreen color with minimal fuss. The bottom line: don't settle for arborvitae just because it's the default. Explore other options, and you might find something that suits your yard better.
If you're still set on arborvitae, let's make sure you set them up for success. Choose a spot with full sun to partial shade — at least 6 hours of direct sunlight per day. The soil should drain well; if water pools after a rain, pick a different spot. I always test drainage by digging a hole and filling it with water. If it drains within a few hours, you're good. If it takes overnight, you need to amend the soil or choose a different plant. Another tip: avoid planting near roads or driveways where salt is used in winter.
Here's my step-by-step planting process that I've used successfully for years. First, dig a hole twice as wide as the root ball but no deeper. You want the top of the root ball level with the ground — planting too deep causes root rot. Second, loosen the soil in the hole and mix in some compost if your soil is poor. Third, place the tree in the hole and backfill with the original soil. Don't add fertilizer at planting time — it can burn the roots. Fourth, water deeply right after planting. I use a slow trickle from a hose for about 30 minutes per tree. Fifth, apply a 2- to 3-inch layer of mulch around the base, keeping it away from the trunk. Mulch keeps the soil cool and moist, which reduces stress. Getting the planting right is one of the most important arborvitae benefits you can give yourself. I've seen too many people skip these steps and then wonder why their trees struggle. One more thing: space them according to their mature size. For 'Green Giant', that means 6 to 8 feet apart. For 'Emerald', 3 to 4 feet. Crowding is the number one mistake I see homeowners make. Give them room, and they'll reward you with a healthy, full hedge.
Once your arborvitae are in the ground, they need consistent care for the first two years. Water deeply once a week during dry spells — about 1 to 2 inches of water per week. In the first year, that means using a soaker hose or drip irrigation. After the second year, they can handle longer dry periods, but don't let them go completely dry. I've learned that a deep watering is better than frequent shallow watering — it encourages deep roots. Another key task: inspect for pests in spring and fall. Look for bagworms, spider mites, and scale. Catch them early, and you can handle them with insecticidal soap or by hand-picking. If you see bagworms, remove the bags and destroy them.
Let me talk about winter care, because this is where many arborvitae fail. In late fall, water deeply before the ground freezes. This helps the trees stay hydrated through winter. Consider using an anti-desiccant spray on the foliage to reduce moisture loss from wind. I've used Wilt Stop on my own arborvitae, and it cuts down on winter burn significantly. For snow-prone areas, gently brush heavy snow off the branches to prevent breakage. Don't shake the branches — that can cause more damage. Use a broom and sweep upward. If you have double leaders, tie them together loosely with soft twine to reduce splitting risk. When you look at arborvitae pros and cons, proper maintenance can shift the balance in your favor. I've seen well-maintained arborvitae hedges that look amazing for 20 years. The difference is, those owners put in the work. Pruning is minimal — just remove dead or damaged branches in spring. If you want to shape them, do it in early summer before the new growth hardens. Never cut back into bare wood, or you'll have a permanent bald spot. With the right care, arborvitae can be a reliable part of your landscape. But don't expect them to thrive on neglect.
So here's the bottom line: arborvitae are a solid choice if you want fast, affordable privacy and you're willing to deal with some quirks. But they're not the only option, and they're not the best option for every situation. I've seen too many people plant them without understanding the arborvitae pros and cons, only to regret it later. My advice: weigh the arborvitae disadvantages and benefits carefully, consider your local conditions, and don't be afraid to mix it up. Your landscape will be healthier, more interesting, and more resilient in the long run. If you take one thing from this article, let it be this: plan ahead, choose wisely, and don't settle for a monoculture. Your yard deserves better — and so do you.
You've probably asked yourself this before: “Why do my arborvitae look like they got sunburned in the middle of winter?” That's winter burn — and it's one of the most frustrating issues I see. Here's what happens: the sun warms the foliage during the day, but the ground stays frozen, so roots can't replace the moisture the leaves lose. The result? Brown, crispy needles on the south and west sides of your trees.
I've dealt with this exact problem more times than I can count. The good news is, you can prevent most winter burn with a few simple steps. Start by watering deeply in late fall — I mean really soaking the ground before it freezes. This gives your trees a reservoir of moisture to draw from. Then, apply a 3- to 4-inch layer of mulch around the base, but keep it off the trunk. I also recommend using an anti-desiccant spray like Wilt-Pruf or Bonide's Wilt Stop. You spray it on the foliage in late fall, and it creates a waxy coating that slows moisture loss. One client of mine sprayed her hedge every November, and her trees stayed green while her neighbor's turned brown every single winter. When you understand the causes behind arborvitae disadvantages and benefits, winter burn becomes much easier to manage. Another trick: if you live in a windy area, wrap your arborvitae in burlap for the winter months. It's not the prettiest look, but it works. I've seen burlap-wrapped hedges come through brutal winters looking perfect, while unprotected trees looked like they'd been through a fire. One more thing — don't prune or fertilize in late summer or fall. That pushes new growth that won't harden off before winter, making winter burn worse. Keep your pruning to early summer, and skip the fall fertilizer entirely.
Let's talk about another common headache: those ugly splits that appear after a heavy snow or ice storm. Arborvitae naturally grow multiple leaders, and those V-shaped forks are weak points. When snow or ice accumulates, the weight forces the branches apart, leaving a permanent gap in your hedge. I've walked through neighborhoods after ice storms and seen rows of arborvitae that looked like they'd been struck by lightning. The damage is heartbreaking, especially if you've spent years growing them.
Here's the thing — you can prevent most of this damage with some proactive care. Start by inspecting your trees in late fall for double leaders. If you spot two main trunks growing in a V shape, you can tie them together loosely with soft twine or tree tape. I use 1-inch wide fabric strips that won't cut into the bark. Leave some slack so the trunks can move naturally, but keep them close enough to support each other. Another key arborvitae pros and cons consideration is snow removal. When heavy snow accumulates on the branches, don't shake the tree — that can snap the branches. Instead, use a soft broom and gently sweep the snow upward, starting from the bottom. I've saved dozens of trees this way over the years. If you live in an area with heavy snowfall, consider installing a snow guard or A-frame structure over your hedge. It sounds like a lot of work, but it's cheaper than replacing an entire row of trees. One client I worked with built a simple wooden frame covered with plastic sheeting, and his arborvitae came through a 2-foot snowfall with zero damage. Another option: choose a variety like 'Emerald' that naturally grows with a single leader and narrower form, which reduces the risk of splitting. When you plan ahead for these structural issues, you save yourself a ton of frustration down the road.
I get this question all the time from homeowners: “Should I plant arborvitae or something else for my privacy screen?” The honest answer is — it depends entirely on your specific conditions. Let me break down how arborvitae stacks up against three common alternatives so you can make an informed choice. I've planted all of these in real landscapes, and I've seen what works and what doesn't.
Let's look at a detailed comparison based on key factors that matter most for privacy screens. I've put together this table using data from cooperative extension offices and my own field experience. The ranges are conservative — your actual results will vary based on your local climate and care.
| Factor | Arborvitae (Thuja) | Leyland Cypress | Japanese Holly | Eastern Red Cedar |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Years to reach 10 ft | 3-5 years | 2-4 years | 6-8 years | 5-7 years |
| Cold hardiness (USDA) | Zones 3-7 | Zones 6-10 | Zones 6-9 | Zones 2-9 |
| Salt tolerance | Low | Moderate | Moderate | High |
| Deer resistance | Low | Moderate | High | Moderate |
| Pest pressure | High (bagworms, mites) | Moderate (canker) | Low | Low |
| Lifespan in ideal conditions | 30-50 years | 20-30 years | 40-60 years | 50-100+ years |
| Root system aggressiveness | Low | High (invasive near foundations) | Low | Moderate |
Here's what this table tells you: if you live in a cold climate (zone 5 or below), arborvitae is one of your few fast-growing evergreen options. That's a big win. But if you're in zone 7 or warmer, Leyland cypress offers similar speed with better pest resistance. Japanese holly is slower but virtually bulletproof once established. Eastern red cedar is a native option that thrives in poor soil and handles salt like a champ. When you weigh arborvitae disadvantages and benefits against these alternatives, the choice becomes clearer. I've planted all four of these in different projects, and I can tell you — there's no universal winner. If deer are your biggest problem, skip arborvitae and go with holly or red cedar. If you need instant screening and live in a mild climate, Leyland cypress is hard to beat. If you're in a cold, salty area, red cedar is your best bet. And if you want the fastest possible screen with the lowest upfront cost, arborvitae still wins — but only if you're willing to manage the risks.
I've seen arborvitae work beautifully in certain situations. They excel in suburban backyards with full sun, well-drained soil, and minimal deer pressure. If you have a fenced yard or live in a neighborhood where deer aren't an issue, arborvitae can give you a fantastic privacy screen in just a few years. I've planted rows of 'Green Giant' in exactly these conditions, and they've thrived for over a decade. They also work well as windbreaks on the north side of a property, where they block cold winter winds without casting too much shade.
But I've also seen arborvitae fail spectacularly. Don't plant them in low-lying areas where water collects — you'll get root rot within a season. Avoid them near roads or driveways where salt spray is a concern. And if you have deer visiting your yard regularly, arborvitae will become a buffet. I had one client who planted 20 arborvitae along her property line, and deer ate every single one down to the ground over two winters. She replaced them with hollies, which the deer left alone. Understanding when arborvitae pros and cons tip in your favor is the key to success. Another no-go zone: tight spaces between houses or near foundations. Arborvitae need room to spread their roots and branches. I've seen them planted 3 feet from a house, and within five years, they were pressing against the siding and causing moisture issues. Give them at least 5 feet of clearance from any structure. Here's another scenario where arborvitae disappoint: if you want a formal, manicured hedge. They don't respond well to heavy shearing, and cutting into old wood leaves permanent bare spots. For a formal look, choose boxwood or yew instead. The bottom line: arborvitae are a tool, not a miracle plant. Use them where they fit, and skip them where they don't. I've learned this lesson the hard way, and I hope you don't have to.
I've put together a simple care calendar that keeps your arborvitae looking their best. Spring (March-May): Inspect for winter damage and prune out any dead or broken branches. Apply a slow-release fertilizer if you want to boost growth — I use a 10-10-10 formula at about half the recommended rate. Also, start watching for bagworms. Look for those small, spindle-shaped bags hanging from the branches. If you see them, pick them off by hand and destroy them. Summer (June-August): Water deeply once a week during dry spells. Check for spider mites — they cause yellowing and fine webbing. If you spot them, blast the foliage with water or use insecticidal soap. Prune for shape in early summer, but never after August.
Fall (September-November): This is the most critical season for prevention. Water deeply before the ground freezes — I do a thorough soaking in late October. Apply anti-desiccant spray in November. If you live in a snowy area, tie up double leaders and consider burlap wrapping. Clean up fallen leaves and debris around the base to reduce disease risk. Winter (December-February): Gently brush heavy snow off branches after storms. Don't let ice accumulate if you can help it. Check for deer browsing and apply repellent if needed. Following this arborvitae pros and cons management schedule makes a huge difference. I've had clients who followed this calendar religiously, and their hedges stayed green and full for 15+ years. The ones who skipped the fall watering or ignored bagworms ended up with patchy, sad-looking rows. One more thing: keep a garden journal. Note when you see pests, what weather extremes hit your area, and how your trees respond. Over time, you'll learn exactly what your specific hedge needs. It's not complicated — it's just consistent.
You can handle most arborvitae care yourself, but some situations call for expert help. If you have a large infestation of bagworms that you can't control by hand-picking, call an arborist. They can apply targeted insecticides that won't harm beneficial insects. Same goes for scale insects or severe spider mite outbreaks. I've seen homeowners spray harsh chemicals and make things worse, while a professional can identify the right treatment. Another time to call a pro: if your trees are leaning or have major splits. They might need cabling or bracing to prevent collapse. But for everyday care — watering, mulching, light pruning — you can absolutely do it yourself. I always tell people: the first two years are the most important. If you put in the effort early, your arborvitae will reward you for decades. When you balance the arborvitae disadvantages and benefits, the DIY approach works for most people. Just don't get lazy about that fall watering routine. I've never regretted spending an extra hour in the garden — but I've definitely regretted skipping it.
E.g. ：Arborvitae Pros And Cons - Disadvantages And Benefits Of ...
Any pros and cons to planting 20 arborvitae for privacy? - Facebook
Green Giants VS Emerald Greens | Lawn Care Forum
Arborvitae. Some love them, some hate them. Read the pros and ...
Emerald green vs American pillar? : r/landscaping - Reddit
A: That's a common selling point, but it's a bit misleading. We hear this all the time from clients who bought arborvitae thinking they could just stick them in the ground and walk away. The truth is, they're low maintenance only after they're fully established, which takes about two to three years. During that period, you absolutely must water them deeply, especially during dry spells — we're talking 1 to 2 inches of water per week. Skip that, and you'll see browning and stunted growth. Even after establishment, they're not completely hands-off. We've seen hedges that looked fine for years suddenly turn brown after a harsh winter or a drought. The low maintenance promise holds up only if you give them ideal conditions: full sun, well-drained soil, and protection from salt and wind. If your yard has heavy clay, poor drainage, or exposure to road salt, arborvitae will demand more from you than you bargained for. So when you're weighing arborvitae pros and cons, remember that "low maintenance" comes with a catch — you need to set them up right first.
A: Browning is the number one complaint we hear, and it usually comes down to three things: watering, winter protection, and site selection. First, water deeply during dry periods — we can't stress this enough. Shallow watering encourages shallow roots, which makes trees more vulnerable to drought stress. Second, prepare for winter. In late fall, water deeply before the ground freezes, then apply an anti-desiccant spray to the foliage. This cuts down on moisture loss from winter winds, which is a major cause of browning. We've used products like Wilt Stop on our own trees, and it makes a noticeable difference. Third, choose your planting site carefully. Avoid low spots where water collects, areas exposed to harsh winds, and spots near roads where salt spray hits the foliage. If you already have browning, check for winter burn — that's the brown, crispy foliage on the windward side. Prune out the dead branches in spring, but don't cut back to bare wood because they won't regrow. Also, inspect for pests like bagworms and spider mites, which cause yellowing and needle drop. If you catch these early, you can treat them with insecticidal soap or by hand-picking. Browning isn't always reversible, but with proper care, you can prevent it from getting worse. Understanding these arborvitae disadvantages and benefits helps you plan ahead and avoid the headache.
A> Yes, unfortunately, splitting is a real issue with arborvitae, and we see it all the time in our landscape work. The problem is that these trees love to grow double leaders — two main trunks that form a V shape. That V is a weak point, and heavy snow, ice, or strong winds can split it right down the middle. We've had clients call us in a panic after a single ice storm destroyed their entire hedge. The good news is you can prevent most splits with a little planning. First, when you buy your trees, look for specimens with a single, strong central leader. Avoid trees with obvious double trunks. If you already have double leaders, you can prune out the weaker one early on — do this when the tree is young and the branches are small. For mature trees, you can tie the leaders together loosely with soft twine or tree tape. This provides support without girdling the bark. Second, protect your trees from heavy snow. Gently brush snow off the branches using a broom — sweep upward, don't shake, which can cause more damage. Third, consider using a snow guard or wrapping the tree loosely with burlap in winter. This reduces the weight load on the branches. Another tip: plant in a location sheltered from strong winds. A windbreak of other trees or a fence can make a huge difference. When we talk about arborvitae disadvantages and benefits, the structural weakness is a major con that many people overlook. But with these steps, you can minimize the risk and keep your hedge looking whole.
A> This is a two-front battle, but both are manageable with consistent effort. Let's start with deer. In areas with high deer populations, arborvitae are like candy — deer love them, especially in winter when other food is scarce. We've seen entire rows of arborvitae stripped bare in a single season. The most effective solution is physical barriers: install fencing at least 6 to 8 feet tall around your hedge, or wrap individual trees in burlap or deer netting. Deer repellents can work, but they need to be reapplied after rain, and deer can get used to them over time. We've had clients rotate between different repellents to keep deer guessing. Another option is to plant deer-resistant alternatives like junipers or hollies, which we'll talk about in a moment. Now, for bagworms — these are tiny caterpillars that build protective bags out of foliage and silk. They can defoliate an entire tree if left unchecked. The best control is hand-picking. In late winter or early spring, inspect your trees and remove any bags you see. Drop them in a bucket of soapy water to kill the eggs. If the infestation is heavy, you can use Bacillus thuringiensis (Bt), a natural bacteria that targets caterpillars. Apply it in late spring when the larvae are actively feeding. We've found that early detection is key — once bagworms mature, they're much harder to control. Also, avoid planting arborvitae too close together, as bagworms spread easily from tree to tree. When you're considering arborvitae pros and cons, these pest and wildlife issues are real drawbacks. But with vigilance, you can keep your hedge healthy.
A> If you're having second thoughts about arborvitae, you've got plenty of solid options that avoid many of the common headaches. Our top recommendation is juniper — upright varieties like 'Skyrocket' or 'Blue Arrow' grow 10 to 15 feet tall, handle drought and salt better than arborvitae, and deer tend to leave them alone. We've planted them in spots where arborvitae would have died, and they thrive with minimal fuss. Holly is another great choice, especially 'Nellie Stevens', which grows fast, stays dense, and produces red berries that birds love. It's also deer-resistant and handles a range of soil conditions. Cypress trees, like Leyland cypress, grow even faster than arborvitae — up to 3 or 4 feet per year — and have stronger wood that resists splitting. They're also more resistant to bagworms. The downside is they can get very tall, up to 50 feet, so make sure you have room. For smaller spaces, consider yew (Taxus). Yews are shade-tolerant, deer-resistant, and respond well to pruning. They don't grow as fast, but they're incredibly reliable and long-lived. If you're set on a fast-growing evergreen, 'Emerald' arborvitae is a smaller, denser variety that's less prone to splitting than 'Green Giant', but it still has the same deer and pest issues. When we weigh arborvitae disadvantages and benefits, the alternatives often come out ahead in terms of long-term reliability. We've seen 20-year-old cypress hedges that look perfect, while arborvitae hedges of the same age have gaps and damage. Don't settle for the default — explore your options.
Recommended
10 Common Vegetable Gardening Mistakes (and How to Fix Them)
Grow Royalty Purple Pod Bush Beans for Beauty and Harvest
10 Best Shade Trees for Southern Yards (Oklahoma, Texas, Arkansas)
Carolina Cabomba: Mistakes I Made Growing It (and How to Fix Them)
